Why brokerage choice matters more than most agents think

A brokerage isn’t a place. It’s a system you join, broker-owner Emily Askin writes. It shapes your risk tolerance, your habits, your professionalism and your long-term sustainability.

Inman On Tour

Inman On Tour Nashville delivers insights, networking, and strategies for agents and leaders navigating today’s market.

Real estate agents have more brokerage choices than ever before. National brands, boutique independents, virtual models, and cloud platforms all promise freedom, flexibility, and better splits. With so many options available, brokerages can all start to look interchangeable.

They are not.

Most agents compare brokerages using the easiest metrics available: commission splits, caps, fees and branding. Those numbers are simple to line up and easy to sell. What they don’t capture is what actually matters when something goes wrong and, eventually, something always does.

Brokerages were once just a little more than a place to hang a license and conduct real estate transactions. That version of real estate no longer exists. Today, brokerages quietly function as compliance managers, educators, systems builders and risk buffers.

As technology expanded agent independence, regulation and liability expanded alongside it. The brokerage didn’t become optional; it became responsible. When that responsibility is handled well, its value is largely invisible.

How culture impacts brokerage choice

“Culture” is one of the most overused words in real estate. It’s often reduced to events, office energy or social media presence. That version of culture is easy to market, but it’s not the one that matters.

Real culture shows up in how standards are enforced, whether accountability is consistent, how leadership handles mistakes and what behavior is quietly tolerated. Culture isn’t what a brokerage says it values. It’s what is allowed to continue.

A well-run brokerage often looks calm on the surface:

Transactions move forward.
Support feels accessible.
Systems appear smooth.

This is The Swan Effect. Underneath all that calm, however, is constant motion.

Contracts change.
Laws evolve.
MLS rules update.
Technology breaks.
Consumer expectations shift.

Every decision, especially the small ones, creates ripple effects across agents, staff and clients. The best brokerages operate like swans. They are composed above water and paddling relentlessly underneath. When done right, agents rarely notice the work. When done wrong, agents feel the consequences immediately.

How strong brokerages impact what matters most

A popular recruiting message in the industry is some version of “we stay out of your way.” It sounds appealing. It also ignores reality. Brokerages serve independent contractors who all think, operate and prioritize differently. Without structure, autonomy turns into inconsistency, and inconsistency creates risk.

Strong brokerages don’t micromanage, but they do standardize where it matters: contracts, advertising, compliance, transaction flow and consumer protection. I prefer to think that freedom works best with guardrails.

I’ve sat in more recruiting rooms than I can count. Most agents don’t ask about systems or risk. They ask about splits. Occasionally tools. Sometimes culture. Very rarely do they ask what happens when a transaction gets hard.

Ironically, that’s often why they leave. When deals fall apart, when emotions rise, when compliance matters, agents don’t exit brokerages over branding — they leave over money or failed systems.

Some agents say they want culture and support, then never engage with either. Others want flexibility, then resent accountability. Agents will often leave a brokerage for the very reasons they joined it.

I’m a broker-owner, and together with my husband and full support team, we operate two brokerages. From this side of the business, one thing is always clear: Every decision has consequences.

Every policy, every exception and every system we implement, or choose not to, affects not just one agent, but the entire ecosystem of agents, staff, clients and the brokerage itself. Sometimes the right decision is popular; sometimes it isn’t, but it’s never accidental.

A brokerage isn’t a place you rent. It’s a system you join. It shapes your risk tolerance, your habits, your professionalism and your long-term sustainability, often far more than your commission split ever will. The most strategic agents don’t ask, “What do I get?” They ask, “What problems does this brokerage solve, and which ones does it quietly ignore?”

Calm is rarely accidental in this business. If it feels that way from your seat, that’s by design. The best brokerages are usually paddling like hell just beneath the surface.

All this month, we’re focused on The New Brokerage Playbook. Running a brokerage in 2026 looks nothing like it used to. From major players to scrappy indies, we’ll map the new playing field and talk with brokerage leaders across the country about what’s working now — and what’s next.

Emily Askin is a broker-owner with REMAX at Home and REMAX Preferred. Connect with her on Instagram.

Topics: independent brokers | RE/MAX Show Comments Hide Comments Sign up for Inman’s Morning Headlines What you need to know to start your day with all the latest industry developments Sign me up By submitting your email address, you agree to receive marketing emails from Inman. Success! Thank you for subscribing to Morning Headlines. Read Next social media and personal connection