Reacts Survey Results: Jaguars fans speak on Josh Hines-Allen’s legacy

Reacts Survey Results: Jaguars fans speak on Josh Hines-Allen’s legacyStory byDec 29, 2024; Jacksonville, Florida, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr. (7) greets a young fan after the game against the Tennessee Titans at EverBank Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Morgan Tencza-Imagn ImagesGus LogueFri, November 28, 2025 at 7:16 PM UTC·5 min read

Last week, we asked Jacksonville Jaguars fans where Josh Hines-Allen ranks among the team’s all-time greats.

Over half of respondents say he’s between the 6th-to-20th best player in franchise history, and a quarter of respondents say he should be inducted into the exclusive Pride of the Jaguars one day.

Top comments from last week’s post:

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

JaxCommenterGuy

Where does Josh Hines-Allen rank among all-time Jaguars?

Not to spoil it for you…but you literally wrote the answer in your article:

Hines-Allen is the most accomplished pass rusher in franchise history. His sack against Justin Herbert on Sunday was the 56th of his career, passing Tony Bracken’s total of 55 for the most by a Jaguar.

And

The New Jersey native also ranks first in tackles for loss (69), first in quarterback hits (137), third in forced fumbles (10), and 17th in combined tackles (323) in franchise history. Sunday was his 100th regular season game, making him just the 30th Jaguar to reach that mark.

TJ-Gators

Hold your horses there. Here’s hoping he builds some consistency in the second half of his career and gets to 100 a little quicker. Von Miller has 134.5 at age 36. Hines-Allen is 28. I know that’s a crazy name to throw out there, but I’m try name a good one who is still currently active.

MCG679

Being the all time leader in sacks for the Jags ain’t saying

much, but he does own it and that can’t be taken away from him.

I mean come on…He’s had 2 seasons out of 6 with 10 plus sacks.

Not exactly top of the league consistently.

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

As far as where he ranks in all time Jags pretty low if you ask me.

NOWHERE NEAR…….

MJD, Boselli, Freddy T

“BIG JOHN” Henderson !!

Mark Brunnel…. aka “THE JAGUAR”

Those guys weren’t just great Jags they were recognized great league wide.

JHA….Isn’t. 😂

Myballzachertz

Here is my top 15:

1. Fred Taylor

2. Tony Boselli

3. Jimmy Smith

4. MJD

5. Marcus Stroud

6. Tony Brackens

7. Keeenan McCardell

8. Mike Peterson

9. Rashean Mathis

10. Daryl Smith

11. Leon Searcy

12. Mark Brunell

12. Brad Meester

13. Josh Hines-Allen

14. Jalen Ramsey

15. Donovan Darius

blackman200

He is in the 15-25 range i feel like

Since he was drafted seventh overall in 2019, Hines-Allen ranks sixth among all EDGE defenders in quarterback hits (138) and 10th in sacks (57.0).

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

His sack numbers could start to catch up with Jacksonville now aligning him across the formation.

Liam Coen was asked about Hines-Allen’s Week 12 deployment on Monday.

“I think we obviously affected the quarterback more. We had 6 sacks, the most since 2023, 15 QB hits. Five guys had sacks. So, I do think that continuing to try to be creative about getting our guys matchups, it’s no different than what you’re trying to do on offense or in special teams when it comes to trying to put your best players in positions to be successful in matchups that you think are favorable in your way. And we’ve got to continue to do that.”

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

As for the confidence survey, 79% of fans are confident in the direction of the team — down from 88% last week.

Top comments from Wednesday’s post:

Badinfuence2832

They keep winning in spite of Trevor. If he can,at the absolute minimum, clean up his game,there’s no end to the season in sight.

I’m also aware that’s a big if

Jaguardian

The Jags need three more victories to get into double digits…two games against the Twit-ans and the woeful Just End The Season (Jets) SHOULD do the trick. Anything else is gravy, just in time for Thanksgiving! Get it done, gentlemen!

GlobalJag

We all wonder what the Jags’ brass is going to do about Trevor, but we should have lots of confidence in the young GM and Head Coach. Six sacks without Travon? Undrafted free agents making an impact on the defensive line? Depleted secondary and different guys stepping up every week? Jacobi Meyers pick up? And on it goes. We’re in good hands.

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

JagKhanVille

Hard to say. We have seen before, teams become hot and in sync late in the season…and make it to the SB. Maybe Trevor will click into place and become clutch in the playoffs.

Regardless, if that does happen…it will be a fleeting moment. I don’t expect Trevor to be much improved in 2026.

WestCoastJagwar

BTJ is back, we will get to see a combo with Meyers. Brenton Strange will have a huge impact in his return as we saw last week. Titans Defense has been notoriously bad with their secondary. I know it’s a division game and things get weird but if ever there was a time to get right and get into a groove with this offense, it’s this week. This is truly an if not when game in my opinion.

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

A belated Happy Thanksgiving to all who celebrate!

AdvertisementAdvertisement